Business Case to secure Capital Funding for a New Children’s Home in Pembrokeshire

The assignment

Sentry Cottage (formerly Ty Cariad) previously operated as a privately run three-bed children’s home. Following a series of critical Care Inspectorate Wales (CIW) inspection reports, the home closed in February 2025, further reducing local placement supply at a time when Pembrokeshire was already heavily reliant on high-cost private placements. In-house provision accounted for just 9.8% of registered children’s residential beds in the county and, of the 41 children in residential placements in December 2025, 26 were placed out of county. 

Pembrokeshire County Council saw the opportunity to acquire the property and bring it back into use as a Council-run, not-for-profit children’s home. Sentry Cottage forms part of a wider programme, which began with the opening of West Lodge in September 2024, to develop six in-house children’s homes and create 24 beds so that children looked after can live closer to home. The Council needed to make the case to Welsh Government for funding from the Health and Social Care Integration and Rebalancing Capital Fund (IRCF) under Priority 3: the removal of profit from children’s residential care. 

So when Pembrokeshire County Council commissioned 31ten to prepare a Green Book compliant Business Justification Case (BJC) for the new home, which is being funded in partnership with Welsh Government through the IRCF, the aim was to secure the capital needed to acquire, refurbish and extend Sentry Cottage as a four-bed children’s home. 

Our role

31ten worked alongside the Council’s Children’s Services, property, finance and procurement teams, through the Children’s Capital Projects Working Group, to deliver a proportionate but robust BJC in line with HM Treasury’s Green Book Five Case Model and Welsh Government BJC guidance. Our work included: 

  • Building the strategic case for change, demonstrating alignment with the Health and Social Care (Wales) Act 2025, the Programme for Government, the West Wales Regional Partnership Board (WWRPB) Strategic Capital Plan and the Council’s Corporate Strategy. 
  • Developing a longlist of eight options with stakeholders through working groups and workshops, appraising them against Critical Success Factors and taking a shortlist forward for net present cost modelling and economic appraisal. 
  • Building a 30-year economic and financial model, using operating costs from West Lodge (an existing Pembrokeshire Council in-house children’s home) and current private placement costs, with sensitivity testing to demonstrate the robustness of the preferred option. 
  • Setting out the commercial case, including procurement of the main contractor through the South West Wales Regional Contractors Framework (SWWRCF) under a fixed-price NEC Option A contract to secure cost certainty. 
  • Developing the management case, covering governance through the Council’s Social Services Capital Programme structures, a costed risk register, benefits realisation and communications plans, and IRCF monitoring and reporting arrangements. 
  • Capturing the voice of the child, reflecting feedback from young people at West Lodge who visited Sentry Cottage and helped shape the design proposals. 

Key Outcomes

  • Preferred option defined: Refurbishing and extending Sentry Cottage to create a compliant four-bed children’s home was the only option to meet all Critical Success Factors in full, and had the lowest net present cost (£19.8m, compared with £23.8m for continued reliance on the private market). 
  • Funding package: The total capital cost of £2.596m is funded through £2.446m of IRCF grant funding (94%) and a £150k Council capital contribution (6%). 
  • Material cost avoidance: The home delivers potential annual savings of up to £485,086 at full occupancy (around £2,326 per child per week compared with private placements), with the preferred option still delivering savings under adverse sensitivity scenarios. 
  • Rebalancing the care market: The project doubles the Council’s in-house residential beds from four to eight, raising its share of registered beds in the county from 9.8% to 17.8% and enabling more children to remain closer to home.
  • Deliverable programme: Main works on a 34-week contract from August 2026, with practical completion in March 2027 within IRCF timescales and the home planned to be operational from September 2027 following CIW registration. 
  • Deliverability secured: With governance, risk management, benefits realisation and stakeholder engagement arrangements in place, the BJC provided a robust platform for the Council’s IRCF funding application.

From approval to operational delivery

Speaking at a 31ten roundtable on delivering in-house children’s homes, Marco Hernandez, the Council’s Responsible Individual and project lead, shared the practical lessons from taking Sentry Cottage from business case to operational home: 

  • Involve the right people early: Children’s Services, property, finance, procurement, HR, operational leadership and regulatory specialists, alongside the Regional Partnership Board and Welsh Government. 
  • Design around the home, not just the build: A children’s home must be designed around regulatory and operational needs, not just construction requirements. 
  • Plan capital and operations in parallel: A completed building is not automatically an operational home. A registered manager and trained workforce, CIW registration, a Statement of Purpose, and safeguarding, medication, recording and quality-assurance systems all need to be in place, so planning in parallel avoids recruitment delays leaving the building unused. 

Read more in the whitepaper from the virtual round table here.

Social value

Alongside the business case, 31ten’s social value offer was designed with the Council rather than for it.

Working with Children’s Services, we identified a need for practical, up-to-date support on the digital lives of children in care, and funded WISE KIDS, a Welsh digital literacy and online safety non-profit, to deliver a full-day workshop for residential care staff and age-appropriate “Getting Digitally Smart” sessions for young people.

The programme, delivered across Pembrokeshire and Carmarthenshire, covered AI and deepfakes, online exploitation, influencer culture and how to report concerns.

Contact

Bernie Lally headshot

Bernie Lally

Principal Consultant

07935 340530 
bernie.lally@31tenconsulting.co.uk